Saying ‘Bye Bye’ To LinkedIn

12 commentsWritten on December 20th, 2009 by
Categories: Rants

I've been on LinkedIn for a while now, and nothing good has ever come out of it. I either get requests to connect with people that i never even met or heard about, or i get harassed by recruiters. These recruiters would call me at my employer's office to discuss ways in which i can "better myself" and when i tell them that it's not a good time to talk (as if there ever is when you're not interested), they ask me if i can send them my email address. Now, i don't want to be an arrogant prick here, but my email address is only a google search away. Why on earth would i even consider talking with a recruiter who hasn't even gone through the trouble of googling me?

As for the people who are requesting me to connect with them even though they never met or worked with me... what is that all about? Except for two or three mistakenly added 'connections' there isn't a single person in my LinkedIn connections list that i didn't either work with previously or know in person. I'm not into the whole 'networking for the purpose of networking' thing. I've done pretty well without it so far, and i'll continue to do fine without it, thank you very much.

I'm also really tired of the hypocrisy that's going on LinkedIn. I often see former co-workers publishing updates about how they're reading about DDD, TDD, Scrum, and agile development practices in general when i know all too well that they don't really care about these things and they're just jumping on the bandwagon. I've also had it with the whole recommendation thing that's going on there... i have quite a few 'connections' on there with people that i've worked with in the past but that i honestly wouldn't recommend to anyone. When you see them hooking up at a certain new employer or project or whatever, and then see them writing recommendations for each other that are just plain dishonest then you can't help but wonder what value the whole recommendation feature of LinkedIn brings in general. Seriously, 3 of the worst people i could ever imagine working with once recommended each other with raving reviews. Wanna go out of business? Hire these 3 people. They'll get along great since they seem to think the world of each other. It wouldn't exactly be a smart business decision though.

That's the biggest problem with something like LinkedIn. People get to pretend that they're important or really good while in reality, most of them aren't. It's full of phonies, who are more than willing to help the other phonies out. So what exactly, is the benefit of being on LinkedIn? Figuring out who knows who? That doesn't mean anything either since a lot of the people on it are adding connections whenever they can, whether they liked working with you or not. The whole thing is basically meaningless. And if you're good at what you do, you really don't need LinkedIn to help you out.

So i tried to delete my account... except that i couldn't. You can hide your account and make it unavailable by selecting the 'None' option in your public profile options (which i did just now), but you can't actually delete it. You have to mail their customer service to actually get them to remove your account. Pretty sad, if you ask me.

How about you? Are you on LinkedIn? Have you ever experienced any benefit whatsoever because of it?

  • Mark

    I’ve had a few prods from recruiters who have found my profile, some of whom are in business in areas I hadn’t considered, but that’s about it. I largely agree that it seems a bit… pointless. Your observation about recommendations is definitely 100% true, though. You can’t stop cliques and friends recommending one another willy-nilly, even if the are the sort of people you’d quit a company to get away from…

  • http://computeristsolutions.com josh

    I’m on it, and the biggest benefit is just keeping tabs on former co-workers. For me and what I do, that can be useful. Other than that, no, not really had a big benefit. Bu then, I’m not big on social media. My limited social media presence is more our of necessity of my job or for personal growth. ..and, occasionally, to help others when I can.

  • Yoeri

    There are indeed a lot of bandwagon-folks on LinkedIn. The main problem is that recruiters are not very technical, they just scan the profiles for buzzwords, the profile that matches their bingo-card is good for the job.

    You will always have this kind of people, except that now it is written on LinkedIn and otherwise they just say they love scrum, tdd, ddd, bdd and other dd’s.

    Most of them write what they want to know, not what they actualy know … kinda sad :-S

  • http://awkwardcoder.blogspot.com/ Awkward Coder

    This sounds familiar! I was on it about 3 years ago and then ‘deleted’ my account for the very reasons you’ve outlined above.

    Do I feel regret now it’s even bigger?

    No

  • Jeronimo

    I agree with you 100% but I am faster :) Mine is closed a few months now:) Cheers!

  • Jeff

    I think there’s value to be had there, but I also think you’re smart to avoid the whole “networking just for networking’s sake” approach. The only people I will add to my network are people who I’ve actually worked with in a meaningful way *and* with whom I’d be willing to work again. Requests falling outside of those criteria just get deleted.

    On the recommendations, I think they’re valuable if you follow the above guideline – that is, if I have recommended someone it’s because I truly think they’re a great person to work with. So hopefully anyone who values my capabilities would see value in people I’m willing to recommend.

    In your example of 3 oxygen-thieves recommending one another, the point holds — a recommendation from someone who added negative value in the past *does* provide feedback. It’s just not necessarily positive feedback. ;-)

  • James

    All the great people I’ve worked with in the past have my email address, and we keep in touch. I really don’t see the point, as its unlikely some random connection from LinkedIn is going to be someone who has some jaw dropping job offer for me.

  • Stef

    Well, whatever you try your Linked-In profile will be there forever!
    I deleted my profile a couple of months ago, tried to log in again yesterday with my old username/password and it worked.
    (and yes I had contacted them to erase my profile)

  • http://davybrion.com Davy Brion

    I found a ‘close my account’ link on their settings page, but apparently my request needs to be approved by customer service because i have over 100 connections. is it even possible to remove connections? :p

    so now i’ve emailed them to close my account, sent 2 official requests to close my account, configured my profile so that none of it should still be public, yet it’s still publicly accessible :s

  • http://jack-fx.com Jack

    I received several invitation, but not accept yet. Based on your post, I’ll not accept it forever

  • http://davybrion.com Davy Brion

    ah, they deleted my account… while it can take another few days before my profile stops showing up in directory listings, i can’t even log in anymore :)

  • http://plan-b-for-openoffice.org/ PlanBForOOo

    Well, you seem to have had a bad experience and little patients for other people’s interests. And you seem to be too young to really benefit from a long term network.

    For me LinkedIn is not a way to keep my friends, as you stated I don’t need online for that. But it is a way to stay in contact with my wider circle. I have lost interesting contacts due to them moving their e-mail (hello friends with ISP addresses I look at you) and/or companies. By the way I’m happy to invite the most boring and uninteresting of my co-workers or other acquaintances. Because sometimes it is useful to not cross paths with certain people again ;-)

    But the most value for me is in helping others, as I make public who I know well enough to introduce contacts to. I make on average one new connection per month (not only per LinkedIn). And many of those have a positive impact. And written (published) recommendations are like any recommendation. It depends on who is giving the recommendation and how well do I know her/him.